This project explores the evolution of character portrayals in Arthurian legends under different authors. The enduring popularity of Arthurian tales has inspired countless adaptations, from medieval literature to modern interpretations. Upon tracing the origins of these stories, I discovered that even in the Middle Ages, authors’ religious beliefs, cultural values, and societal preferences significantly influenced their depiction of characters. This variability in character portrayal mirrors the creative dynamics of modern fanfiction, inspiring the intriguing title of this project. Focusing on Gawain, Arthur’s nephew, I examine his transformation from a notable figure in early works like The History of the Kings of Britain to a character whose role shifted under the influence of later “foreign” knights such as Tristan and Lancelot, illustrating how authors’ differing priorities shape a character’s identity across time.